Evaluating AI tools in WA is easier when the comparison begins with one business task and a spending limit. A tool that produces an impressive demonstration may still be unsuitable for the information, staff capacity or consequences involved. The first project should make those questions visible before the business makes a wider commitment.
Compare both the task and the way it will be performed. For a small service business, drafting an internal summary from approved sample notes is a different proposition from allowing software to answer customers or change bookings automatically.
Internal assistance versus decisions affecting customers
An internal draft can be checked before anyone relies on it. A customer-facing answer or automated decision can create consequences before an employee notices an error. Compare the impact of a mistake, not merely the similarity of the words the tool produces.
The National AI Centre’s solution guidance connects the choice with task impact, data and required oversight. Use those considerations to select a first project whose outputs can be reviewed by someone who understands the subject.
For a WA business, local names, service boundaries and industry terms need checking. A plausible description of another place or a service the business does not offer is still an error. Do not judge accuracy only by spelling or a fluent tone.
An existing feature versus a separate tool
Software already used by the business may offer an AI feature, while a separate tool may provide a different capability. Compare the actual controls and costs for the relevant plan. Existing access does not automatically mean the feature is included or approved for your information.
A separate tool may allow a bounded test without changing the main system, but introduces another account and possibly another transfer of information. Consider how staff would supply inputs, review outputs and bring an approved result back into the workflow.
The government’s AI business guidance recommends identifying problems, testing tools and checking outputs. Treat the first project as an evaluation of the complete task, rather than a contest between product demonstrations.
Sample information versus live business records
Non-sensitive sample material can help test whether the tool follows instructions and produces a useful format. Prepare examples with known answers, including an incomplete note or an ambiguity. Clearly label any invented sample so it is not confused with an actual customer record.
Live information may introduce confidentiality, privacy, contractual and security questions. Check the provider’s terms, data use, storage, retention and access arrangements before supplying it. Removing a name alone does not establish that a record is safe to upload.
The ASD’s AI security guidance highlights information sharing, provider practices, output reliability and the risks of excessive agent permissions. A first project should not quietly give a tool authority to send messages, change records or approve transactions.
Subscription price versus the project budget
A subscription buys access, while a project also needs preparation and review. Include staff time for learning, selecting sample inputs, checking answers, correcting errors and documenting the result. These costs can continue even when the tool is free to try.
- The initial and renewal price for the required plan.
- Usage limits and charges for additional activity.
- Time spent preparing suitable inputs.
- Time needed to verify and correct outputs.
- Integration, support and record export requirements.
Set a maximum commitment for the trial, including internal effort. Avoid an annual payment solely because its monthly equivalent looks lower if you have not established that the tool fits the task. Record the terms that apply when a promotional period ends.
Fast output versus a dependable completed task
Compare the total time to an acceptable result. An instant draft can lose its advantage if it introduces unsupported details or needs extensive rewriting. Keep the original task available so the reviewer can check what was omitted or changed.
Use the same sample cases and evaluation criteria for shortlisted tools and the existing method. Assess factual accuracy, relevant omissions, usable format and the effort required. Record failures as well as successful examples.
One good answer does not establish consistent performance. Include ordinary variation and a case where the correct response is to ask for clarification. An evaluation should reveal when staff must stop and use another method.
A bounded pilot versus immediate rollout
A pilot gives one person responsibility, restricts the information used and sets a review date. A wider rollout creates more users, inputs and exceptions. Compare whether the evidence from the pilot actually supports that additional scope.
Keep a record of the tool version, relevant settings and date of the test where available. A later update or different configuration may change behaviour. The comparison should be reproducible enough for another authorised reviewer to understand what was actually evaluated.
Choose in advance what would justify continuing, revising or stopping. Keep the findings and unresolved risks with the budget. The useful first AI project is one the business can explain, supervise and afford, with a clear human decision about what happens next.